The Bread and Butter Cafe

Fresh Homemade Pies



Here is a list of our most popular fresh homemade pies. All of our pies are made from scratch and we only use the freshest ingredients when the season is right. If there is a pie you would like us to make for you give us a call and we will do our best to accommodate you!

In the restaurant we sell 10-15 various varieties of pie by the slice daily. Our whole pies must be ordered 24 hours in advanced.

Chocolate Cream

Banana Cream

Coconut Cream

Almond joy

Peanut butter Cream

Chocolate-Peanut butter Cream

Butterscotch Cream

Strawberry Cream

Strawberry-Banana Cream

Chocolate-Strawberry Cream

Chocolate-Banana Cream

Raspberry Cream

Blueberry Cream

Blackberry Cream

Rocky Road Cream

Pineapple Cream

Pina Colada Cream

Hawaiian Cream

Orange Cream

Vanilla Cream

Peanut butter-Banana Cream

Mint Chocolate Cream

Candy Cane Cream

Elvis Cream

Apple

Dutch Apple

Sugar free Apple

Cherry

Rhubarb

Strawberry-Rhubarb

Raspberry-Rhubarb

Raspberry

Blueberry

Strawberry

Blackberry

Peach

Peach Cobbler

Kentucky Pecan

Coconut Pineapple

Mincemeat

Pumpkin

Custard

Lemon Meringue

Orange Meringue

Gooseberry Meringue

Chocolate Brownie Pecan

Lemon-Berry

Mixed Berry Crumb

Key Lime

Pineapple Meringue

Prickly Pear Meringue

Smores

Avocado

Cookie Dough

Website Builder